Smaller, Smarter, Solvent

POST 3 OF 7 | LIBERTARIANISM FOR THE 21ST CENTURY

Smaller and efficient government

Smaller, Smarter, Solvent

Balanced budgets, sunset clauses, department eliminations — what a fiscally responsible libertarian government actually looks like in practice

Once you’ve accepted that the debt is real and has to be dealt with — which Post 2 argued is the essential first move — the next question is practical: what does a genuinely smaller government actually look like, and how do you get there without chaos?

This is where libertarian thinking has some of its best ideas, and also where it has historically done the worst job of communicating them to ordinary voters. ‘Abolish the Department of Education’ sounds radical. ‘Return education decisions to states, localities, and families while eliminating a federal bureaucracy that has produced no measurable improvement in outcomes despite fifty years of operation’ is an argument. Those are different things.

The Balanced Budget Mandate

A constitutional balanced budget requirement is one of the few issues that can genuinely unite both libertarian factions. Purists hate deficit spending because it funds state expansion through deferred coercion. Pragmatists hate it because it’s fiscally irresponsible and crowds out private investment. The political class hates it because it removes their favorite tool for buying votes without raising taxes.

That last point is actually the strongest argument for it. A balanced budget requirement forces explicit tradeoffs. Every new spending priority has to displace an existing one or be funded by a visible tax increase. Suddenly the real costs of government programs become undeniable. That’s a profoundly libertarian outcome even if the mechanism is a government rule.

Sunset Clauses on Everything

One of the most practical and underappreciated reforms in libertarian thinking is the universal sunset clause — a rule that every government program, agency, and expenditure has an automatic expiration date unless affirmatively reauthorized.

Under current practice, programs are essentially immortal. Once created, they build constituencies, hire staff, and develop political patrons. Eliminating them requires active effort against organized resistance. Sunset clauses flip the default: inaction means the program ends, not that it continues. Continuation requires justification.

Applied universally, this single reform would do more to shrink government over time than almost any other single measure — without requiring anyone to make a dramatic ideological argument. It just requires legislators to affirmatively answer ‘is this still working?’ on a regular schedule.

Which Departments Can Actually Go

Here’s where the conversation needs to be honest rather than reflexive. Not every federal department is equally defensible or indefensible. Some have clear constitutional grounding and perform functions genuinely requiring national coordination. Others are harder to justify.

Departments with strong cases for significant reduction or elimination include the Department of Education (educational outcomes are a state and local function with no evidence federal involvement improves them), the Department of Energy’s non-nuclear functions (research subsidies that mostly benefit well-connected industries), the Department of Commerce outside of census functions, and significant portions of the Department of Agriculture that function primarily as corporate welfare for large agribusiness.

Departments that require reform rather than elimination include Defense (which needs auditing and efficiency — it has never passed one), the VA (which has genuine constitutional obligations to veterans), and the Department of Transportation (where infrastructure has real public goods characteristics that markets undersupply).

The Audit Comes First

Here’s the 21st-century discipline that libertarian governance requires: you audit before you cut. The federal government has never had a complete, clean financial audit. The Department of Defense alone has failed its audit five consecutive times. Nobody actually knows what is being spent on what, with what efficiency, producing what outcomes.

Cutting without auditing is like performing surgery blindfolded. You might hit the right thing. You’re more likely to cause damage you didn’t intend. A serious smaller-government agenda starts with complete transparency about what exists, not ideological dartboard throwing.

Smaller, smarter, solvent. In that order. That’s a platform that can actually be defended to voters who aren’t already libertarians — which is the only kind of platform that can ever win.

Next: Post 4 — Freedom Means Everyone

Leave a Reply

Is this your new site? Log in to activate admin features and dismiss this message
Log In